Cl@ve or digital certificate: which do you need in Spain?
Cl@ve vs the FNMT digital certificate compared: what each does, how to get them with an NIE, signing, renewals and which to get first.
Based on 7 official sources · Sources checked
On this page
Both let you log in to Spanish government websites. The FNMT certificate is a file on your computer or phone. It works almost everywhere and signs documents. Cl@ve is a phone-based login that is easy day to day. With an NIE, get the certificate first: it takes one office visit and then lets you register for Cl@ve online in minutes.
Key facts
- Certificate
- Free file from the FNMT. Logs you in and signs documents. Needs one office visit for most foreigners.
- Cl@ve
- Free phone login. Cl@ve Móvil uses an app, Cl@ve Permanente a password, plus an SMS code for sensitive services.
- Our advice
- Get the certificate first, then use it to register for Cl@ve at the advanced level.
- Both need
- A DNI or NIE.
- Signing
- The certificate signs anywhere signatures are accepted. Cl@ve signs only where Cl@ve Firma is offered.
The short version
Most people who live in Spain end up with both. The question is which to get first.
Get the certificate first if you have an NIE. Video registration for Cl@ve needs a Spanish DNI, so foreigners register by invitation letter, with a certificate or at an office. The office page only mentions bringing a DNI, so check with the office before you go with an NIE. The certificate route is instant and gives you the highest Cl@ve level. One trip to an office for the certificate solves both.
Side by side
| Topic | FNMT certificate | Cl@ve |
|---|---|---|
| What it is | A file installed in your browser or phone | A login through the Cl@ve app or a password plus SMS |
| Cost | Free | Free |
| How foreigners get it | Request online, show documents at an office, download | With a certificate online, by invitation letter, or at an office (the office page mentions a DNI, so check first) |
| Logging in | Pick the certificate in a browser pop-up | Scan a QR code and confirm on your phone |
| Signing documents | Yes, wherever a certificate signature is accepted | Only with Cl@ve Firma, on services that offer it, and only at the advanced level |
| Where it lives | On each device where you install the backup | On one phone per person |
| Renewal | Renew in the 60 days before it expires. Online renewal has limits. | The Cl@ve Permanente password expires every year |
| Best for | Signing, tax returns, anything formal | Quick logins from your phone |
When the certificate is the better choice
- You need to sign and submit forms online, not just look things up.
- You do things for a business or as a self-employed worker (autónomo).
- You want one login that works on any computer where you install it.
- You want to register for Cl@ve at the advanced level without an extra office visit.
When Cl@ve is the better choice
- You mainly check things on your phone, such as your Carpeta Ciudadana or your driving licence points with the traffic authority (DGT).
- You use a shared or work computer where you should not install a certificate.
- You lost access to your certificate and need a backup login.
- You have a Spanish DNI, so you can register by video in a few minutes.
How each one handles signing
With a certificate you can sign any form or document where the service accepts an electronic signature.
Cl@ve can sign too, through Cl@ve Firma. The signing certificate is kept on government servers. You need the advanced level, an active Cl@ve Permanente password and an SMS code each time. It only works on services that have added Cl@ve Firma, and more are being added over time. If you have not proved your identity in person or with an electronic DNI (DNIe) for five years, you must do that again before you can sign.
The order we recommend
Get your NIE
Both need a DNI or NIE. Sort that out first.
Official page: FNMT: Certificado Electrónico de Ciudadano
Get the FNMT certificate
Request it online, visit an office with your documents, and download it after the visit (FNMT says within about an hour). Make a backup the same day.
Register for Cl@ve with the certificate
On clave.gob.es, choose the route with a certificate. You get the advanced level and an activation code in minutes.
Official page: Cl@ve: ¿Cómo puedo registrarme?
Install the Cl@ve app
Use it for quick logins on your phone. Keep the certificate for signing and for when the app does not work.
Where you can use them
Cl@ve says it works on all national government e-services, all regional governments and most councils. Look for the Cl@ve button on the login page. Examples include the Carpeta Ciudadana, your income tax return, tax data and DGT driving licence points. A service can still limit which methods it accepts, for example when it handles specially protected personal data.
FNMT lists tax filing, padrón procedures and signing official forms among the uses of its certificate. Most login pages show the certificate as an option next to Cl@ve.
Common mistakes
Useful Spanish
- certificado digital
- Digital certificate, usually the FNMT one.
- Cl@ve Móvil
- Cl@ve login with the Cl@ve app.
- Cl@ve Permanente
- Cl@ve login with a password, plus an SMS code for sensitive services.
- Cl@ve Firma
- Signing with a certificate kept on government servers.
- firma electrónica
- Electronic signature.
- identificarse
- To identify yourself, to log in.Login pages often say "Identifícate" or "Acceso".
- apoderamiento
- Formal authorisation for someone to act for you.
- sede electrónica
- An authority's official e-services website.
Frequently asked questions
Do I need both Cl@ve and a certificate?
No, one is enough to start. Many people end up with both, because the certificate signs documents and Cl@ve is quick on a phone.
Which is easier for a foreigner with an NIE?
The certificate. You need one office visit, and then you can register for Cl@ve online with it.
Can Cl@ve sign documents?
Yes, with Cl@ve Firma, on services that offer it. You need the advanced level and Cl@ve Permanente.
Do they cost anything?
No. Both are free. Only FNMT video identification costs 2.99 euros plus tax, and that needs a Spanish DNI.
What happens if I lose my phone?
Your certificate on your computer still works. Use it to change the mobile number linked to your Cl@ve.
Independent guide. Follow the instructions of the authority handling your case.
Sources
- Cl@ve: ¿Qué es Cl@ve?clave.gob.es
- Cl@ve: ¿Dónde puedo usar Cl@ve?clave.gob.es
- Cl@ve: preguntas frecuentesclave.gob.es
- Cl@ve: ¿Cómo puedo registrarme?clave.gob.es
- Cl@ve Firma: funcionamientoclave.gob.es
- FNMT: Certificado Electrónico de Ciudadanosede.fnmt.gob.es
- FNMT: Renovar certificadosede.fnmt.gob.es